Home
 
 
 
Navigation  
  Previous Entry
Next Entry
 
July 2009  
 
 1234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293031
 


  Powered by
LiveJournal.com  
 

Advertisement

Free Speech Where do We Draw the Line?  
09:35am 13/05/2008
 
 
queerunity
A few interesting and controversial headlines have popped up in the news and the gay blogosphere that raise some important questions. At what point is gay activism intruding upon free speech and freedom of expression rights? Freedom of speech and expression must be protected even for anti-gay forces, because if we don't have these basic freedoms it becomes a slippery slope and eventually we will not have the right to express our opinions.

I write this in light of some stories recently, such as a student who wore a t-shirt to school saying "Be Happy - Not Gay!" at a diversity event, who got in trouble. The courts have since ruled she is entitled to wear the shirt.

What about Crystal Dixon's case with the University of Toledo V.P. of Human Resources who outside the university wrote an opinion column denouncing homosexuality, claiming it is a choice. She has been fired under grounds that she mentioned she was a worker at the school and is now suing the school.

Finally there was the case at Smith College, where the College Republicans brought in Ryan Sorba who created a book called "The Born Gay Hoax" who spoke about bogus research regarding LGBT people. Students interrupted his anti-gay speech by screaming "We're Here, We're Queer, get used to it" the student protesters overwhelmed the room forcing Mr. Sorba to leave the campus and cancel his speech.

Youtube clip of the Smith protest:


What do you think about GLBT activism and where do we draw the line to ensure free speech rights, or is it okay to intrude upon the free speech of others when they seek to intrude on our civil liberties and spread falsehoods about our community?

http://queersunited.blogspot.com/2008/05/open-forum-free-speech-where-do-we-draw.html
 
    Post - Read 1 - Add to Memories - Tell a Friend - Link
 

(no subject)
 thehat
 
06:41pm 13/05/2008 (UTC)
 
 
TheHat
Let's see... Down the list:

The kid with the t-shirt has the right to protest. As long as he was only protesting and not trying to start a fight, then there's nothing wrong with the t-shirt.

The University of Toledo's VP of Human Resources has the right to voice her opinion, but as soon as she mentions working for the school then the school has the right to distance itself from that opinion.

Now, the Ryan Sorba case gets trickier. The basis of Ryan Sorba's opinion is based on pseudo-science. Sure, he has a right to say what he wants, but that does not make his opinion equal to others. The students didn't use the most productive way to shut him up, and they were probably violating his freedom of speech with their actions. However, the First Amendment does not protect you from other people, it simply protects you from the government. When you're "teaching" pseudo-science at a school then someone needs to stop it. If he wants to be taken seriously, then he needs to perform studies that back up his hypothesis and present them at scientific conferences. Only then can he present them to the public.
 
    Reply - Thread - Link
 


Advertisement